Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Glenn Beck, "Amazing Grace," 2010

Two a.m. and I've been packing for a big move for hours. An unpleasant chore, so I gave it an unpleasant soundtrack -- the three-and-a-half hour video of Glenn Beck's "Restoring Honor Rally," on C-Span. I've been reporting on the American right for close to a decade now, so I've mostly gotten past the snark with which lefties respond to this sort of thing. I'm more fascinated by the craft of mass movement manipulation. For the first couple of hours, I was thinking that Beck was genius. Because the rally really wasn't explicitly political, not even Palin, and there were Native Americans and black preachers and MLK, and even if it didn't make sense -- if Beck was stealing history -- he seemed to be getting away with it. That is, he was successfully passing off the radical witness of MLK as prelude to the almost all white crowd on hand. That great white crowd would leave feeling itself redeemed from and inoculated against charges of racism. The use of veterans, too, was masterful -- never about the war, always about the soldiers. Beck can say anything he wants now -- he's proven, to his followers, that he is above politics.

"So what?" says the liberal. His followers are, after all, his followers, right? Not exactly. He needs not only to keep them but to keep them moving. Beck isn't Rush; Rush appeals to the cranky, while Beck speaks to discontent. Rush satisfies his fans' cynicism; Beck offers them hope. Or, rather, promises them that it's up ahead, and there's danger behind -- keep moving, nation.

So I'm watching out of the corner of my eye while I pack, admiring the craft of manipulation, when Beck starts winding it down with the story of John Newton, the slave trader turned clergyman who wrote "Amazing Grace." Beck, predictably, mangles the story, as he has every other moment of history he's stroked during the rally. But what catches me off guard is Beck's description of the song as the best ever written for the bagpipes. Cue bagpipes.

Now, I like bagpipes, too, but "Amazing Grace" wasn't written for bagpipes -- a military instrument. It's not a militant song, but Beck, tipping his hand at the end, makes it a battle hymn. A few more songs follow, but that's the big finale -- Beck has closed his rally like Mel Gibson's Passion of the Christ. Remember, the boulder rolled away from the tomb, and the marching music rising, Christ rising too, to go kick some ass? That was Gibson's real theological sleight of hand, the replacement of the lamb with the action hero, muscular Christianity on steroids. Beck has followed his lead, turning the plaintive beauty of "Amazing Grace" into a war song. I know, firemen and policemen killed on the job sometimes get "Amazing Grace" with bagpipes. But somehow this is different. Those are funerals; this is a movement rising, getting read to kick some ass. It's the only moment in this really kind of dull rally that galls me -- the only real crack in Beck's facade of democratic pluralism. 

5 comments:

trib said...

Excellent post, Jeff. Thanks for all that you do. I am in Mississippi and can attest that the old white folks here are true believers. It's curious that they throw aside their theological distrust of Mormons to follow Mr. Beck. But you can't build a movement by being too theologically pure... one has to practical.
Heil Beck!

Becky said...

Thanks - also check out the military imagery in Xn hymns. Scary, creepy and unfortunately spot on.

Ditty said...

Thanks Jeff.
I saw large segments of this speech and, on its face, it was mind blowingly offensive so I assume many "liberals" and African Americans turned away. Who would want to lend it press or attention? But, as you gleaned, the agenda espoused was riddled with subtleties that when examined, reveal a sort of mass mind-washing that is souring the milk of liberty. A virulent hate appears every increasingly mainstream under the guise of a patriotic grassroots movement riddled with hope blossomed from hate. Many more should have tuned into this broadcast to study the mechanisms of these Bob Robert's tactics that are quietly birthing Terry Jones seedlings across the country. And all the prominent conservative can offer is to tell their good soldiers to "stand down" and not to "feed the fire." That is, until the time is right, and the movement is galvanized under the arches of political power.

Anonymous said...

Cubic zirconias are the best choice for thomas sabo those of you who doesn't thomas sabo charms want to spend too much money on thomas sabo jewellery buying a diamond engagement ring but still want something that looks almost identical. thomas sabo charms sale Let's face it, wouldn't it make more sabo charms sense to save the money for a new car instead? cheap thomas sabo charms With cubic zirconia's, the only way to tell the difference between it and a thomas sabo jewellry diamond is to get a professional jeweler to have a look at it. discount thomas sabo charms To untrained eye, it looks just the same. thomas sabo sale charms The other advantage to zirconia's is that you can choose from a range of colors, and pick the most suitable color of stone for the engagement ring.

paul [silentsanta] said...

I have a strong feeling that the bagpipes-and-snare-drums rendition of Amazing Grace was heavily inspired by -or perhaps lifted verbatim from- its use in the 2006 Michael Apted film "Amazing Grace" about William Wilberforce, one more film that was virally passed around the evangelical Christian circuit. There too, it is the anthem of a movement rising.